Monday, 12 August 2013

Amendment takes Human Error into Account

In the National Budget, presented on 27 February 2013, the Minister of Finance indicated that the rules regulating the imposition of the understatement penalty in terms of the Tax Administration Act, No 28 of 2011, would be amended to deal with those case where a taxpayer made an inadvertent error in filing a tax return with the South African Revenue Service.  

This was on the basis that, without the amendment, a taxpayer could have faced a penalty of 25% or 50%, even though the taxpayer had made a genuine mistake such as a transposition error in filing their return.

Previously, under section 76 of the Income Tax Act, No 58 of 1962, as amended (‘the Act’), the Commissioner was empowered to levy additional tax of 200% of the tax which should have been paid by a taxpayer.  

The Commissioner was then conferred a discretion to reduce the additional tax where there were extenuating circumstances, and, furthermore, it was required that the taxpayer had the intent to evade taxation for the additional tax to be imposed.  

Thus, the provisions contained in section 76 of the Act were subject to the exercise of a discretion by the Commissioner, and determined by taking account of subjective criteria.

With the introduction of the Tax Administration Act, the penalty regime was revised to introduce objective criteria such that the amount of penalty would be determined by the taxpayer’s behaviour.

Currently, the understatement penalties which may be levied by SARS under the Tax Administration Act are as follows:

Item
Behaviour
Standard Case
If obstructive or if it is a ‘repeat case’
Voluntary disclosure after notification of audit
Voluntary disclosure before notification of audit
(i)
‘Substantial understatement’
25%
50%
5%
0%
(ii)
Reasonable care not taken in completing return
50%
75%
25%
0%
(iii)
No reasonable grounds for ‘tax position’ taken
75%
100%
35%
0%
(iv)
Gross negligence
100%
125%
50%
5%
(v)
Intentional tax evasion
150%
200%
75%
10%

Section 221 defines a “substantial understatement” as a case where the prejudice to SARS exceeds a rate of 5% of  the tax  properly chargeable or refundable under a tax act for the relevant tax period or the amount of R1 million.  

Thus, where a taxpayer submits a tax return which is subsequently audited by SARS and an adjustment is made thereto such that the tax payable is increased by R1 million or 5% of the amount of tax properly chargeable under a tax act, the penalty which may be levied may amount to 25% for the first occasion of such an event or 50% where the taxpayer has previously been subjected to an understatement penalty within the last five years.

Thus, the quantum of the understatement penalty which may be levied on a taxpayer will be determined by the taxpayer’s behaviour and the level of penalty will increase depending on the nature of the behaviour of the taxpayer.

On 4 July 2013, the National Treasury released the draft Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 for comment.  That Bill proposes various changes to the imposition of the understatement penalty such that the level of penalties is reduced in various cases.  

Accordingly, the revised table will take effect on that date that the Bill is promulgated. 
The Bill therefore proposes that the understatement penalty table be amended along the following lines:

Item
Behaviour
Standard Case
If obstructive or if it is a ‘repeat case’
Voluntary disclosure after notification of audit
Voluntary disclosure before notification of audit
(i)
‘Substantial understatement’
10%
20%
5%
0%
(ii)
Reasonable care not taken in completing return
25%
50%
15%
0%
(iii)
No reasonable grounds for ‘tax position’ taken
50%
75%
25%
0%
(iv)
Gross negligence
100%
125%
50%
5%
(v)
Intentional tax evasion
150%
200%
75%
10%

The draft memorandum on the objects of the Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 indicates that the rationale for amending section 223 is to align the percentage of the penalty with comparative tax jurisdictions where largely similar penalty regimes apply. 

The Bill reduces the level of understatement penalty in respect of substantial understatement, reasonable care not taken in completing a return and no reasonable grounds for tax position taken by the taxpayer.

The version of the draft Bill released on 4 July 2013 indicated that the reduction in the level of understatement penalty would take effect from 1 October 2012.  

However, on 5 July 2013, the SARS website indicated that the draft Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 and its memorandum of objects had been replaced with new versions.  

From a review of the versions released on 5 July 2013, it is apparent that it is now proposed that the effect date of the changes in the level on understatement penalty will be the date on which the Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 is enacted.  

Those taxpayers who have received assessments from SARS and have been subjected to the understatement penalty will feel aggrieved in that the level of understatement penalty imposed on them is greater than what will be applied to taxpayers in future years, even though SARS admits that the sanctions originally contained in section 223 of the Tax Administration Bill were out of line with comparative tax jurisdictions where similar penalty regimes are applied.

It must be remembered that SARS is compelled to remit a penalty imposed for a substantial understatement in terms of section 223(3) of the Tax Administration Act where the taxpayer made full disclosure of the arrangement as defined in section 34 of the Tax Administration Act that gave rise to the prejudice to SARS by no later than the date that the relevant return was due to SARS and was in possession of an opinion by a registered tax practitioner in the prescribed form.  

The draft Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 proposes an amendment to section 223(3)(b) that the opinion must be issued by an independent tax practitioner.  The draft memorandum on the Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill 2013 indicates that the amendment requires that the opinion relied on by the taxpayer must be given by a tax practitioner that is independent from the taxpayer.  

The commentary on the draft Bill indicates that opinions prepared by in-house tax practitioners, in, for example, a large corporate group, will not qualify as a result of their potential vested interests relating to such matters.

The Bill also proposes an amendment to section 224 of the Tax Administration Act, stating unequivocally that a taxpayer has the right to object and appeal against an understatement penalty.  It is questionable whether this amendment is necessary in light of the provisions contained in section 104 of the Tax Administration Act, which confers the right to object against assessments issued to taxpayers.

It is clear that the reduced level in the quantum of the understatement penalties proposed in the draft Bill are not as onerous as the level of penalties currently contained in the Tax Administration Act.  It is unfortunate that the amendments will not benefit those taxpayers who have been subjected to understatement penalties since 1 October 2012.

In practice, it would appear that SARS takes the view that the understatement penalty should apply to all adjustments made to tax returns submitted by taxpayers, even where those tax returns were submitted prior to 1 October 2012, that is, the date on which the Tax Administration Act took effect.  

Based on the rule of law and the principles relating to the interpretation of statutes, it would appear that the provisions of section 270(6) of the Tax Administration Act should require SARS to consider imposing additional tax, in the case of income tax, under section 76 of the Act, or other equivalent provisions in other tax acts, in respect of events which took place prior to 1 October 2012 and not to levy the prescriptive understatement penalty contained in section 223 of the Tax Administration Act.  

No doubt the interpretation of the application of the understatement penalty to adjustments made after 1 October 2012 to tax assessments relating to years of assessment prior to 1 October 2012 will, ultimately, be determined by the courts.

 ■ Dr Beric Croome is a tax executive at ENS. This article first appeared in Business Day, Business Law and Tax Review, Aug 2013. 

Monday, 5 August 2013

The Future Taxation of Trusts

In the National Budget, tabled in Parliament on February 27, the Minister of Finance indi­cated that government was proposing several legislative measures during 2013/14 to curtail perceived tax avoidance associated with trusts. The Treasury also indicated its concern regarding the use of trusts to avoid estate duty, which it intended to review.

It was pointed out that the proposals in the budget would not apply to those trusts established to cater for the needs of minor children and people with disabilities,that is, so called special trusts.

Originally,   Treasury   indicated that discretionary trusts should no longer act as flow-through vehicles, with the result that a trust should be taxed as a separate and distinct entity. It was expected that legislation would be introduced whereby trusts would be liable to pay tax in their own right, without the possibility of passing income and capital gains through to beneficiaries.

However, the budget documentation was somewhat unclear in that it indicated that, to the extent that a trust derives taxable income and distributes that to a beneficiary, such amount would be deductible for the trust, and the beneficiary would then be taxed thereon as having received ordinary revenue.

The Minister of Finance indicated that trading trusts would similarly be taxable at the entity level, with distributions being treated as deductible payments to the extent of the trust's taxable income. It was pointed out that trusts would be regarded as trading trusts where they either conducted a trade or where the beneficial ownership interests in the trust were freely transferrable.

National Treasury is concerned 
that trusts are being used for tax avoidance  purposes
Some years ago, government attempted to define trading trusts in order to regulate the manner in which such trusts should be taxed, but eventually abandoned the idea, because it was unable to comprehensively define what should constitute a trading trust.

Finally, the budget indicated that distributions received from offshore foundations will always be treated as ordinary revenue in the future.

To  date, no draft legislation has been released setting out the manner in which government intends to deal with the taxation of trusts in the future.

On June 14, a meeting was held by representatives of the National Trea­sury and the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service with representatives of the Fiduciary Institute of Southern Africa, Financial Planning Institute, Law Society of South Africa, South African Institute of Chartered Accountants, South African Institute of Tax Practitioners and the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners, to discuss the taxation of trusts in the future.

It would appear that National Treasury is concerned that trusts are being used for tax avoidance purposes, and wishes to understand the position better.

The delegates to the meeting were also asked how frequently founda­tions are used and the reasons there­ fore. It was indicated that founda­tions are not widely used, and this aspect will probably be investigated further.

In addition, the meeting discussed interaction between the Master's Of­fice and the Commissioner: SARS. It is more than likely that the tax returns submitted by trusts will be­ come more onerous, so that greater disclosure regarding the activities conducted by trusts will be made to SARS.

The National Budget estimated that estate duty would contribute some R900 million in the 2013/14 fiscal year, which represents a small part of budgeted state revenue. It remains unclear why estate duty continues to exist. Ideally, the taxation of trusts, capital gains tax and estate duty should be reviewed holistically to formulate a sound fiscal policy.

The Minister of Finance announced on February 27 that Judge D Davis of the High Court would chair a commission of enquiry into the tax structure of South Africa. It is hoped that that commission will review the taxation of trusts in South Africa, taking account of the capital gains tax and estate duty implications relating thereto.

National Treasury indicated in the meeting held on June 14 that no tax changes regarding trusts have been finalised, and that any amendments proposed to the taxation of trusts will be discussed in depth, and a discussion paper released for comment, but this is not likely to happen in the short term.

The 2013 Taxation Laws Amendment Bill has been released, which contains most of the amendments required to give effect to the tax policy decisions contained in the 2013 budget.

Taking account of the meeting held on June 14, no amendments to the taxation of trusts are contained in the 2013 Taxation Laws Amendment Bill, but the matter will be properly reviewed and considered before amendments are made. This move should be supported, as it is far better that the taxation of trusts is reviewed holistically than introducing ad-hoc amendments to address perceived tax avoidance.

Dr Beric Croome is an executive in the Tax department at Edward Nathan  Sonnenbergs. This article first appeared in tax ENSight, June 2013 and in The Times newspaper, Legal Times supplement on 2 August 2013.

Tuesday, 9 July 2013

Tax Evaders Find it Difficult to Hide Across Borders

South Africa and the United Kingdom concluded a convention for the avoidance of double taxation and the prevention of fiscal evasion with respect to taxes on income and capital gains, which was gazetted in Government Gazette 24335 of 31 January 2003.  That agreement was subsequently amended by Government Notice 52 in Government Gazette 34971 on 2 February 2012 with effect from 13 October 2011.

The amendments to the treaty concluded by South Africa and the United Kingdom dealt with, inter alia, the exchange of information regulated by article 25 and article 25A dealing with assistance in the collection of taxes.

SARS  and  UK  revenue   can assist in targeting 
tax debtors in each other's countries
Article 25A of the treaty provides that the South African Revenue Service (‘SARS’) and Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (‘HMRC’) shall assist each other in the collection of taxes.

Article 25A refers to any amount owed in respect of taxes of every kind and description imposed on behalf of South Africa and the United Kingdom or of their political subdivisions or local authorities, so long as the taxation in question is not contrary to the tax treaty or any other instrument to which the two countries are parties, as well as interest, administrative penalties and the cost of collection or conversancy related to such tax.

The treaty provides that, where a tax debt is enforceable under the laws of South Africa, and is owed by a person who cannot under the laws of South Africa prevent its collection, that tax debt shall, at the request of the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service be accepted for purposes of collection by the competent authority of the United Kingdom.  Article 25A(3) provides that the tax debt shall be collected by the United Kingdom in accordance with the provisions of its laws applicable to the enforcement and collection of its own taxes, as if that debt were an amount due to the United Kingdom.  The treaty also requires South Africa to assist the United Kingdom in collecting tax debts due by United Kingdom taxpayers from assets they may have in South Africa.

Before the insertion of article 25A into the tax treaty, SARS was unable to assist HMRC in the collection of taxes due to it from assets of United Kingdom taxpayers located in South Africa  and, similarly, HMRC was unable to assist SARS in recovering taxes due to SARS from assets located in the United Kingdom belonging to South African taxpayers.  The question that did arise at the time that the article was inserted into the treaty, was whether the assistance in the collection of taxes could apply to taxes which arose prior to the insertion of the article into the tax treaty.

This question was considered in the United Kingdom’s Court of Appeal in the case of Ben Nevis (Holdings) Ltd and Anor v Commissioner for HM Revenue and Customs [2013] EWCA Civ 578.  Ben Nevis is a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands, which was owned and controlled by a Mr David King and/or his trustees.  The judgment indicates that Ben Nevis is liable to the Commissioner: SARS for taxes from the 1998 to the 2000 years of assessment amounting to approximately R2,6 billion following the final determination of a tax appeal in October 2010.  Subsequently, judgment was taken against Ben Nevis in proceedings in the courts in South Africa.

SARS took the view that, when Mr King became aware that SARS was investigating Ben Nevis’ tax affairs, he transferred Ben Nevis’ assets to another company incorporated in British Virgin Islands, and that, as a result thereof, funds of approximately £7,8 million had been credited to a bank account in London in the name of Metlika Trading Limited.

As a result of the protocol amending the tax treaty between South Africa and the United Kingdom taking effect on 13 October 2011, which now, for the first time, allowed for mutual assistance in the collection of taxes, a request was made by SARS to HMRC that it assist SARS in the collection of the tax debt due.

The High Court in the United Kingdom had previously dismissed Ben Nevis’ application to set aside the order granting judgment against Ben Nevis in respect of the tax due to SARS.

Historically, the courts in the United Kingdom have declined the request to entertain claims for the enforcement of revenue or other public laws of a foreign state.  This flows from the well-established principle that the courts of one country will not enforce the revenue laws of another country.  However, this principle has been watered down as a result of international agreements concluded by various governments, and, particularly, the Joint Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters, which include a provision for assistance in the recovery of taxes.

Originally, as pointed out above, the tax treaty concluded by South Africa and the United Kingdom did not contain any provision for mutual assistance in the collection of taxes.  Article 25A was inserted by virtue of the protocol conclude by the two governments, with effect from 13th October 2011.

Ben Nevis sought to argue that article 25A of the tax treaty could not apply  as a result of the fact that the tax debts were due in respect of years of assessment commencing prior to the coming into force of the 2002 convention concluded by South Africa and the United Kingdom.  Thus, Ben Nevis sought to argue that the effect of article 25A and article 27 of the 2002 convention limited the scope of article 25A to tax debts on or after 1 January 2003.  The tax owed by Ben Nevis related to the 1998 to 2000 assessments, that is, prior to the 2002 convention and most certainly prior to the date on which article 25A was inserted into the tax treaty concluded between South Africa and the United Kingdom.

Lord Justice Lloyd Jones reviewed various cases dealing with the interpretation of international agreements and also the relevant articles of the Vienna Convention on Treaties and considered the retrospective effect of article 25A.

The Court also referred to a memorandum of understanding that was agreed to by South Africa and the United Kingdom and criticised the fact such memorandum could only be obtained by taxpayers by making a Freedom of Information Act request.  The Court, therefore, expressed the view that it is in the interest of fairness to taxpayers that memoranda of understanding agreed by contracting states should be readily available to the public.

The Court reached the conclusion that the application of article 25A to a request for assistance in the enforcement of tax debts arising before the protocol came into effect did not amount to retrospective application, nor was it unfair that the protocol should apply to such pre-existing tax liabilities.  The Court also considered the effect of the Finance Act of 2006, and whether that Act permitted HMRC to conclude an agreement with another country such that mutual assistance in the collection of tax debt should apply retrospectively.

At the end of the day, the Court decided that the presumption against retrospective effect did not apply to Ben Nevis, because the application of article 25A in respect of taxes arising before 19 July 2006, that is, the date on which the relevant provisions of the Finance Act took effect, or 1 January 2003, did not involve any objectionable retrospective effect.  The Court accordingly decided that article 25A could be utilised by HMRC in assisting SARS in recovering tax liabilities which arose prior to the insertion of article 25A into the tax treaty concluded by South Africa and the United Kingdom.

It is interesting to note that the tax treaty concluded by South Africa and Australia contains a similar provision dealing with the assistance in the collection of taxes at article 25A which appeared in Government Gazette 31721 of 23 December 2008.  The press has reported that Mr Tannenbaum, the alleged mastermind of a Ponzi scheme, is indebted to SARS in the amount of R747,990,921.00.  Mr Tannenbaum would appear to currently reside in Australia, and, when reference is made to the decision in the Ben Nevis case, it is more than likely that SARS will seek assistance from the Australian Tax Office to recover the taxes due as a result of the alleged Ponzi by relying on article 25A of the treaty concluded by South Africa and Australia.

Previously, tax treaties did not envisage countries assisting each other in the collection of tax debts, but this has changed, and the OECD’s Model Convention now contains such provisions. Furthermore, the Joint Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Matters includes a provision for the assistance in recovery of taxes.  

Thus, governments will assist each other in recovering taxes due by taxpayers of other countries from assets that those taxpayers may have in the other country.

■ Dr Beric Croome is a tax executive at ENS. This article first appeared in Business Day, Business Law and Tax Review, July 2013. 

Wednesday, 26 June 2013

The Future Taxation of Trusts

In the National Budget, tabled in Parliament on 27th February 2013, the Minister of Finance indicated that government was proposing several legislative measures during 2013/14 regarding trusts to curtail perceived tax avoidance associated with trusts.  The Treasury also indicated its concern regarding the use of trusts to avoid estate duty, which it intended to review.

It was pointed out that the proposals in the Budget would not apply to those trusts established to cater for the needs of minor children and people with disabilities, that is, so-called special trusts.

Originally, Treasury indicated that discretionary trusts should no longer act as flow-through vehicles, with the result that a trust should be taxed as a separate and distinct entity.  It was expected that legislation would be introduced whereby trusts would be liable to pay tax in its' own right without the possibility of passing income and capital gains through to beneficiaries.  

However, the Budget documentation was somewhat unclear in that it indicated that, to the extent that a trust derives taxable income and distributes that to a beneficiary, such amount would be deductible for the trust, and the beneficiary would then be taxed thereon as having received ordinary revenue.

The Minister of Finance indicated that trading trusts would similarly be taxable at the entity level, with distributions being treated as deductible payments to the extent of the trust’s taxable income.  It was pointed out that trusts would be regarded as trading trusts where they either conducted a trade or where the beneficial ownership interests in the trust were freely transferrable.  Some years ago, government attempted to define trading trusts in order to regulate the manner in which such trusts should be taxed, but eventually abandoned the idea because it was unable to comprehensively define what should constitute a trading trust.

Finally, the budget indicated that distributions received from offshore foundations will always be treated as ordinary revenue in the future.

To date, no draft legislation has been released setting out the manner in which government intends to deal with the taxation of trusts in the future.

On 14th June 2013, a meeting was held by representatives of the National Treasury and the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service with representatives of the Fiduciary Institute of Southern Africa, Financial Planning Institute, Law Society of South Africa, South African Institute of Chartered Accountants, South African Institute of Tax Practitioners and the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners, to discuss the taxation of trusts in the future.

It would appear that National Treasury is concerned that trusts are being used for tax avoidance purposes, and it appears that National Treasury wishes to understand the position better.

The delegates of the meeting were also asked how frequently foundations are used and the reasons therefore.  It was indicated that foundations are not widely used, and this aspect will probably be investigated further.

In addition, the meeting discussed interaction between the Master’s Office and the Commissioner: SARS.  It is more than likely that the tax returns submitted by trusts will become more onerous so that greater disclosure regarding the activities conducted by trusts are fully disclosed to SARS.

The National Budget estimated that estate duty would contribute some R900 million in the 2013/14 fiscal year, which represents a small part of budgeted state revenue.  It remains unclear why estate duty continues to exist.  Ideally, the taxation of trusts, capital gains tax and estate duty should be reviewed holistically to formulate a sound fiscal policy.  The Minister of Finance announced on 27th February 2013 that Judge D Davis of the High Court would chair a commission of enquiry into the tax structure of South Africa.  It is hoped that that commission will review the taxation of trusts in South Africa, taking account of the capital gains tax and estate duty implications relating thereto.

National Treasury indicated in the meeting held on 14th June 2013 that no tax changes regarding trusts have been finalised, and that any amendments proposed to the taxation of trusts will be discussed in depth and a discussion paper released for comment, but this is not likely to happen in the short term.

The 2013 Taxation laws Amendment Bill is due to be released shortly, which will contain most of the amendments required to give effect to the tax policy decisions contained in the 2013 Budget.

Taking account of the meeting held on 14th June 2013, it would appear that no amendments to the taxation of trusts will be contained in the 2013 Taxation Laws Amendment Bill, but that the matter will be properly reviewed and considered before amendments are made.  This move should be supported, as it is far better that the taxation of trusts is reviewed holistically as opposed to introducing ad-hoc amendments to address perceived tax avoidance.


Monday, 10 June 2013

Receiver Throws Information Net Wider

On 5th April 2013, the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service issued Government Notice number 260, which appeared in Government Gazette number 36346 on 5th April 2013, setting out returns of information which must be submitted by third parties in terms of section 26 of the Tax Administration Act, No 28 of 2011. 

It is appropriate to point out that, on 29th February 2012, the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service published a Government Notice requiring reporting institutions to furnish bi-annual returns of investment and interest with effect from the 2013 year of assessment.  That government notice required certain financial institutions to supply extensive information to the Commissioner: SARS.  As a result of the Tax Administration Act taking effect, it was necessary for a new notice to be published specifying information to be supplied by various third parties to Commissioner: SARS.

Hackles may rise as this move could be seen as a violation of the taxpayer’s right to privacy
At the time that the Tax Administration Act was being finalised, it was indicated that the legislation was being enhanced to improve the gathering of information from third parties by the Commissioner: South African Revenue Service, so as to increase the levels of tax compliance in South Africa and to assist in the further pre-population of tax returns to be submitted by individuals.

The latest notice requires financial institutions to supply details of retirement annuity contributions paid by taxpayers and for medical aid schemes to supply details of contributions made by persons in respect of the medical scheme, as well as all expenses paid for a person by a medical scheme.  

These two particular requirements will assist SARS in pre-populating tax returns to be lodged by individuals.  In addition, financial institutions in receipt of premiums paid for income protection policies must disclose that to the Commissioner, which should assist taxpayers in satisfying the Commissioner: SARS as to the deductibility of premiums paid on income protection policies.

The notice issued on 5th April 2013 requires the following persons to submit a return in the manner prescribed in the notice:

  •          banks regulated by the registrar of banks in terms of the Banks Act or the Mutual Banks Act;
  •          co-operative banks regulated by the Co-operative Banks Development Agency in terms of the Co-operatives Banks Act;

  •          the South African Post Bank Limited, regulated in terms of the South African Post Bank Limited Act;
  •          financial institutions regulated by the executive officer, deputy executive officer or board, as defined in the Financial Services Board Act, whether in terms of that Act or any other act;

  •          companies listed on the JSE and connected persons in relation to the companies that issue bonds, debentures or similar financial instruments;

  •          state-owned companies, as defined in section 1 of the Companies Act that issue bonds, debentures or similar financial instruments;

  •          organs of state, as defined in section 239 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa that issue bonds, debentures or similar financial instruments;

  •          any person, including a co-operative, as defined in section 1 of the Income Tax Act, who purchases any livestock, produce, timber, ore, mineral or previous stones from a primary producer other than on a retail basis;

  •          any medical scheme registered under section 24 of the Medical Schemes Act;

  •          any person who, for their own account, carries on the business as an estate agent, as defined in the Estate Agency Affairs Act and who pays to or receives on behalf of a third party any amount in respect of any investment, interest or the rental of property; and

  •          any person who, for their own account, practices as an attorney, as defined in section 1 of the Attorneys Act, and who pays to or receives on behalf of a third party any amount in respect of any investment, interest or the rental of property.


The notice then describes the nature of the information to be provided by the categories of persons specified in the notice.  The Commissioner is seeking information regarding amounts paid or received in respect of or by way of any investment, rental of immovable property, interest or royalty, and transactions that are recorded in an account maintained for another person, that is, so-called transactional accounts like bank accounts.

Furthermore, those persons involved in the purchase and disposal of financial instruments for clients are required to disclose details of amounts paid in respect of the purchase and disposal of financial instruments.

Insurance companies are required to report the payment of amounts made upon the death of a person in terms of an insurance policy.

Monies paid in respect of the purchase, sale or shipment of livestock, timber, ore, mineral, precious stones or by way of a bonus, in the case of a co-operative, are required to be disclosed to the Commissioner by affected persons.

The affected third parties are required to submit the requisite IT3 form to the Commissioner, or, alternatively, a data file compiled in accordance with SARS’s business requirements specification for IT3 data submission.

The requirement to submit information to the Commissioner is onerous in that the returns specified in the notice containing all information required in respect of the period from 1 March to 31 August of each tax year must be submitted by 31 October and, in respect of the period from 1 March to the end of February, must be submitted by 31 May.  This increases the administrative burden on the affected persons, and will, no doubt, require amendments to computer systems to facilitate the transfer of data electronically to the Commissioner.

It is indicated that, where the third party return comprises twenty or less detailed records, the declaration portion of the return and detailed portion of the return must be submitted electronically using the SARS e-filing platform, or manually to the SARS office closest to the person’s place of business.

For those larger organisations, and where the third party return comprises twenty-one to fifty thousand detailed records, it is necessary to submit the declaration electronically using SARS’s e-filing platform, and the detailed portion of the return must be submitted electronically, using SARS’ hypertext transfer protocol secure (https) bulk data file platform. 

In the event that the third party return comprises more than fifty thousand detailed records, the declaration portion of the return must be submitted electronically using SARS’ e-filing platform, and the detailed portion of the return must be submitted electronically, using SARS’ managed data transfer platform.

The Government Notice provides that alternative arrangements may be made by affected persons as to how the information should be transferred or made available to SARS.

The Government Notice was issued so as to enable SARS to enhance third party information received by it, to ensure enhanced compliance with the tax laws of South Africa, and, also, to facilitate a greater degree of pre-populating of tax returns issued by SARS for completion by individuals.

Some commentators may seek to argue that the provision of the information called for violates the taxpayer’s right to privacy, but it must be remembered that any right contained in the Constitution is capable of limitation under section 36 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, No 108 of 1996, as amended.  

The request of the information set out in the notice may be construed as a violation of the right to privacy, but it is necessary for SARS to call for such information in order to comply with its obligations in administering the tax laws of South Africa, and, on this basis, the limitation of rights provision contained in section 36 of the Constitution would assist SARS should the information called for be challenged by taxpayers or affected persons.  

■ Dr Beric Croome is a tax executive at ENS.This article first appeared in Business Day, Business Law & Tax Review, June 2013. Free Image from FreeDigitalImages

Friday, 7 June 2013

Forum On Tax Administration – Moscow Meeting

The Forum on Tax Administration (‘FTA’), comprising the heads of tax administrations from 45 economies, met in Moscow for the 8th meeting of the FTA.  The final communiqué issued pursuant to the Moscow meeting indicated that the FTA is dedicated to securing high levels of voluntary tax compliance by providing excellent service and effectively addressing tax evasion and aggressive tax avoidance in all its forms, including the underground economy.
The communiqué indicated that the participating tax administrations are committed to undertaking action jointly to improve the effectiveness of tax administrations, address trans-national tax fraud, tax evasion and aggressive tax avoidance.

The Moscow communiqué pointed out that, where the tax administrations are detecting offshore evasion, they will share information with their partner countries.  It was pointed out that tools have been developed to enhance the gathering of information and cross-border financial transfers, to understand banking transactions and to identify the beneficial owners of complex structures.  Furthermore, Australia, the United Kingdom and the United States of America have secured significant data revealing complex offshore structures, which will be utilised by the revenue authorities in those countries to identify participants in tax evasion and take action against those persons where necessary.  It would appear that the three countries concerned will share the information obtained by them to other members of the FTA in accordance with international agreements.

Over the last few years, the number of agreements allowing for the exchange of information between countries has increased, and this has facilitated the greater flow of tax information between states.  The FTA has indicated that it will rely more and more on the provisions of the increased network of agreements, allowing for the exchange of information and, also, by providing necessary training to tax auditors to ensure the effective and secure use of information received under the various international agreements.  It must be noted that the automatic exchange of information between states has increased, and that this will ultimately become the standard to which various countries will comply under international agreements.

The Moscow communiqué also referred to the OECD’s work on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (‘BEPS’), which will initiate an action plan intended to modernise international tax instruments and standards to counter BEPS, particularly in the area of international taxation, transfer pricing and the digital economy, in an effective manner.  Governments around the world are concerned about the erosion of their tax base and shifting of profits to lower tax jurisdictions, particularly in the current economic climate, which has created difficulties for tax authorities collecting sufficient tax for the various governments around the world.

In addition, the communiqué indicates that tax administrations must enhance their efficiency and offer their citizens and business quality service and support for voluntary compliance.  It was pointed out that the effective management of tax debts, including tax debts that arise cross-border, is a key priority, and will be a particular focus of attention in the future.
When reference is made to the various initiatives underway, such as the OECD’s BEPS initiative, the work of the FTA and other organisations, it is important that businesses review the manner in which they conduct their tax affairs to ensure that they comply with their fiscal obligations in the various countries within which they operate.

All revenue administrations need also to take account of the rights which taxpayers have in their dealings with the revenue authority, and South African taxpayers can seek reliance on the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996, in ensuring that their rights are not violated by SARS.  Various organisations have undertaken research into the design of a model taxpayers’ charter to prescribe levels of taxpayers’ rights to protect taxpayers in their dealings with tax administrations around the world.

It is important, taking account of the pressures facing revenue authorities to raise revenue in difficult economic times, that taxpayers’ rights are protected, and are not disregarded when collecting tax that the revenue authorities believe may be due.

This article by Dr Beric Croome first appeared in the May 2013 edition of tax ENSight newsletter.  Free image from ClipArt